| Platinum | Sammy's Pizza & Bigfoot Bar |
| Gold | Cloverleaf Pizza |
| Silver | Katie Downs |
| Bronze | The Cloverleaf |
| Top Pick | Domino's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Farrelli's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Godfather's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Manuscript |
| Top Pick | Salamone's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Spud's Pizza Parlor |