| Platinum | Brewers Row |
| Gold | Taqueria El Sabor |
| Silver | Tacos Guaymas |
| Bronze | Moctezuma's Mexican Restaurant & Tequila Bar |
| Top Pick | El Toro Mexican Restaurant & Cantina |
| Top Pick | Indita Mia Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Maria's Cocina Mexicana |
| Top Pick | Matador Tacoma |
| Top Pick | Poquitos Tacoma |
| Top Pick | Red Star Taco Bar |